Regulators approve TEP rate increase and yearly rate reviews
PHOENIX — State regulators voted 4-1 on Tuesday, Nov. 17, to raise Tucson Electric Power's rates and to let TEP adjust its rates every year from now on, instead of waiting years between rate cases. Commissioner Lea Márquez Peterson cast the only no vote.
The Arizona Corporation Commission, which sets the rates TEP can charge, changed the plan in more than a dozen votes over an eight-hour meeting before approving it. TEP has to file new estimates showing what those changes mean for customers' bills.
Two of the four commissioners who voted yes are leaving the commission. Chair Nick Myers lost the Republican primary in July. Commissioner Kevin Thompson lost his reelection bid on Nov. 3, when Democrats Clara Pratte and Jonathon Hill won both open seats. They take office next year, ending the Republicans' hold on all five seats. Hill watched part of Tuesday's meeting from the audience.
What it means for your bill
Before Tuesday's changes, TEP estimated the plan would add about $12.93 to the average home's monthly bill, or 9.4%, bringing it to about $151 a month. RUCO, the state office that represents residential customers, put the increase at more than 11% for most residential customers.
Neither figure reflects Tuesday's amendments. The new rates take effect Dec. 1, according to the Arizona Attorney General's Office.
Other pieces that reach customers directly:
- The fixed monthly charge goes up $2.50. Every home pays this charge no matter how much electricity it uses. TEP had asked for $5. Márquez Peterson's proposal to drop the increase failed 1-4.
- Future yearly increases won't go on that fixed charge. They'll be added to the price per kilowatt-hour instead, so customers who use less pay less of them. That passed 4-1, with Commissioner René Lopez voting no.
- A two-tier discount program for low-income customers stays in the plan.
- Customers won't pay for TEP's meals, entertainment and gifts. The judge who heard the case had cut half of those costs; the commission cut all of them, 5-0. RUCO said TEP gave it only 25 invoices to back up more than $1 million in meal costs. TEP said it had offered to show RUCO the rest in person and that its crews travel across the state.
- Customers will get the interest TEP earns on about $85 million in federal tax credits while TEP holds the money, 5-0.
TEP's last rate increase was in 2023. RUCO said this is the third increase TEP has sought in about six years, after residential increases of 6.8% in 2021 and 9.5% in 2023.
TEP's chief executive, Susan Gray, said the utility has invested $1.7 billion in its grid since its last rate case, including its Roadrunner Reserve battery storage. She said TEP first asked for a 13% increase and later cut its request by nearly $40 million.
Rate changes every year
The biggest change is how TEP's rates will be set from now on. Until now, TEP's rates changed only after a full rate case, every few years. Under the new system, which the commission calls an annual rate adjustment mechanism, TEP will file each year to adjust its rates, and the commission has to vote on each one.
Supporters on the commission said yearly reviews should mean smaller, steadier changes instead of big jumps every few years. They said nothing is automatic: the commission votes on each year's adjustment and can suspend the system.
Márquez Peterson's proposal to reject the yearly system failed 1-4. She said the old way, where a utility waits years between increases, keeps its spending in check, and that the yearly system mainly benefits the company. RUCO, the Arizona Attorney General's Office and a solar industry group backed her proposal.
A group of large business customers warned that TEP has asked federal regulators for a 55% increase in its transmission rates from 2026 to 2027. They said that increase would flow straight into TEP's first yearly adjustment.
The commission put some limits on the yearly system:
- The share of TEP's money that comes from its owners, rather than from borrowing, is capped at 55.5% in the yearly filings, 5-0. Critics in the case said a higher share would push rates up.
- TEP can count equipment finished after its test period only in its first yearly filing, 3-2. TEP said that will slow how quickly it recovers those costs.
TEP's profit rate
Regulators also set how much profit TEP is allowed to earn on its investments, called the return on equity. The judge had recommended 9.65%.
Vice Chair Rachel Walden's amendment cut it to 9.4%, 3-2, with Chair Nick Myers and Commissioner Kevin Thompson voting no. Walden said the yearly system makes TEP's business less risky, so it should earn less. Commission staff opposed the cut, saying its own expert's lowest recommendation was 9.5%.
Myers then won a second vote, also 3-2, that adds back a return on the "fair value increment," an accounting measure of TEP's property value that the judge had left out. Walden and Márquez Peterson voted no. Myers said the plan was penalizing TEP three times for adopting the yearly system. TEP's lawyer said the two votes together work out to roughly a 9.67% return, close to what the judge recommended.
Walden said she was disappointed Myers' amendment passed but would still vote for the rate increase.
Time-of-use rates and data centers
Time-of-use rates charge more for electricity during the busiest hours of the day and less at other times. More than 80,000 TEP customers, over 20% of residential customers, are on TEP's standard time-of-use plan, TEP said.
Márquez Peterson first proposed narrowing TEP's high-price evening window from 3–7 p.m. to 4–7 p.m. The commission was told the case record could support a trial program but not new rates. She revised the amendment so TEP must propose a time-of-use pilot for homes and small businesses by June 1, 2027, to start Oct. 1, 2027. It passed 5-0.
The commission also voted 5-0 for a Walden amendment on very large customers, such as data centers. TEP and the other parties in the case have 180 days to propose when TEP should have to study what those customers cost to serve. That replaced a broader data-center rate proposed by the Attorney General's Office, which TEP said wasn't supported by the case record.
TEP said the Project Blue data center is paying all of its own substation costs. TEP also said Project Blue isn't part of this rate case, which is based on TEP's costs through Dec. 31, 2024.
Other votes
- Lopez's amendment letting TEP charge customers for half of its non-lobbying dues to the Edison Electric Institute, a utility trade group, passed 4-1. Walden voted no.
- A Thompson amendment passed 4-1, with Márquez Peterson voting no. It keeps several other ways for TEP to recover costs, including a low-income rate adjustment, in place if the yearly system is ever ended.
- Márquez Peterson's proposal to make it easier for TEP's yearly adjustments to lower rates failed 1-4. So did her proposal to change how TEP passes fuel and purchased-power costs on to customers. Thompson said an earlier change like it helped TEP's unpaid fuel costs grow to about $50 million, which customers then paid off through a surcharge.
- Lopez's proposal requiring TEP to check whether customers it told about cheaper rate plans actually switched and saved failed 2-3. Lopez and Thompson voted yes.
The Arizona Attorney General's Office, which represents the state in the case, renewed its request that Myers step aside from the case. He stayed on and voted.
Several Tucson residents asked the commission to reject the increase, citing affordability and data center growth. One asked commissioners to hold off until the newly elected members take office, and to hold TEP hearings in Tucson rather than Phoenix.
Also at the meeting
- UNS Gas: Commissioners discussed how the yearly rate system they approved for UNS Gas in February is working. Staff said it was working as expected. RUCO said it couldn't fully check the company's numbers. RUCO also said UNS Gas' Sept. 1 filing asked for a 7.7% increase that could end up over 8%; the company disputed that. UNS Gas agreed to send spreadsheets RUCO can analyze and to answer such requests within 10 days. No vote was taken.
- Consent agenda: Approved 5-0. It included siting approvals for two Salt River Project projects in Pinal County: about 4.5 miles of transmission lines and the Marigold Thermal Plant.
- Lopez joined remotely for about the first 90 minutes, then attended in person.
Updated Nov. 18, 2026, 11:20 a.m.: added the date the new rates take effect, from the Arizona Attorney General's Office.
This report was drafted by Claude Opus 5.5 from a live transcript produced by Deepgram Nova-2, then reviewed and edited by Nicholas De Leon with Claude Opus 5.5, and published at 5:07 PM MST on November 17, 2026. Read more about how this is made.
Comments
Join the conversation on Bluesky