From the Old Pueblo

Tucson Daily Brief

The Tucson news you’d otherwise miss, by Nicholas De Leon.

What They Decided

Families pack TUSD hearing to fight school closures, and two board members say they're a no

TUCSON — Parents, teachers, students and neighbors spent hours Tuesday, Nov. 17, asking the Tucson Unified School District board not to close or merge seven schools. By the end of the night, two of the five board members said they would vote against the plan as it stands, and a third said the Collier piece of it won't work.

The board took no action. It's scheduled to vote Dec. 8 at Palo Verde High School. Three no votes would be a majority of the five-member board.

The meeting, a public hearing at Sahuaro High School followed by the board's discussion, ran nearly 4½ hours.

The plan

The district's proposals would close seven schools and send their students to other campuses:

  • Starting in 2027-28: Collier into Bloom Elementary, Cragin into Blenman Elementary and Hudlow into Sewell Elementary.
  • Starting in 2028-29: Magee Middle School into Sabino High School, Cavett Elementary into Utterback Middle School, Secrist Middle School into Santa Rita High School and Steele K-6 into Booth-Fickett K-8.

What families and teachers told the board

Speakers came from nearly every school on the list. Many questioned the district's estimate that 85% of students from closed schools would stay in TUSD.

  • Collier: The PTA shared an anonymous survey of 19 families representing 24 current students. Of the 18 families with children enrolled now, every one said those children would leave TUSD if Collier closed. The PTA asked the board to instead try a three-year pilot turning Collier into a preschool-through-eighth-grade "Sonoran Desert Learning School."
  • Collier students: Five students also asked the board to keep the school open. "You're not shutting down a building," one said. "You're shutting down a community where kids have fun and learn." Another told the board, "Money isn't all that matters," and added, "I don't want to go to sixth grade in a high school."
  • Cragin and Hudlow: Parents and staff said both schools recently raised their state grade from a D to a B.
  • Hudlow: Parents and staff said a grant for a new roof at Sewell drove the decision to close Hudlow. A former member of the district's boundaries committee said Sewell was built for 350 students and pointed to a planned 133-home development nearby.
  • Steele: A teacher said about 40% of students come from 10 nearby apartment complexes and about 44% get special education services.
  • Secrist: A teacher said Superintendent Gabriel Trujillo had told staff they would all move to Santa Rita, down to the monitors and custodians, and that staff later learned the school would lose 4.4 full-time positions.
  • Magee: Several parents said they worry about putting 11-year-olds on a high school campus.
  • The teachers union: Jim Byrne, president of the Tucson Education Association, said the union "cannot support the proposed plan for closures and consolidations as currently presented." Byrne said a new state administration could bring TUSD $141 million in capital funding.
  • Other ideas: Speakers urged the district to cut administrative pay and to lease, rather than sell, any closed campuses.

Where the board stands

Jennifer Eckstrom: "Right now, I'm a no." Eckstrom said she would support closures only if most of the affected community was on board, and that families haven't been part of the planning. She called the process "way too rushed," saying the district hadn't surveyed Magee families or asked Steele families how their children would get to school if they could no longer walk. Trujillo confirmed that surveying families wasn't part of the district consultant's job.

Sadie Shaw: "I think we should vote no on these proposals." Shaw said she hoped a third board member would join. She pointed to other places to save money first:

  • a transportation audit she said could save upward of $7 million
  • about $3 million in administrative spending
  • a $16 million error by the district's finance department
  • the district's $16 million administration building

She also criticized the 0% enrollment-growth goal set in the superintendent's renewed contract, which she said she voted against.

Val Romero: some closures, but not Collier's. Romero said he has argued publicly that the district needs to close 17 schools "to right side this district," and that doing nothing risks a high-risk designation from the state Auditor General. "I know we need to close some schools," he said, but "Collier to Bloom, two different communities, they're not gonna work out."

Romero also argued for Steele. He said its kindergarten-through-third-grade proficiency rose from 24% to 53.5% last year, compared with 18% to 32% at Booth-Fickett, and that two staffed special education classrooms at Steele sit empty when filling them could bring in about $130,000 each. He said Magee is 7.8 miles from Sabino but under 3 miles from Gridley and Booth-Fickett.

Ravi Shah and Natalie Luna Rose asked questions but didn't say Tuesday how they'd vote. Shah, the board president, asked whether Sabino and Santa Rita should take only seventh through 12th graders, leaving sixth graders at their elementary schools. Luna Rose, the board clerk, asked how the plan to turn Cavett into a campus for students with high needs, most with autism, would work. Trujillo and a district special education administrator said no student would be placed there automatically. A team that includes the parent would decide, and only after other options had been tried.

Other questions from the board

  • Sports: Shaw asked how middle and high school teams would share fields and gyms at Sabino and Santa Rita. Trujillo said high school sports would be scheduled first, some locker rooms would need changes and middle school flag football might move to spring.
  • Dual language: The district's language acquisition director said the director's team called fourth- and fifth-grade families in Bloom's two-way dual language program, and most wanted to keep the path from Magee to Sabino. Gridley could be an option for families who don't want a sixth-through-12th-grade campus, the director said.
  • New housing: Staff said they expect six to seven students from new apartments near Collier, and that they hadn't found new housing near Hudlow but would look again.
  • The schools' own plans: Eckstrom asked whether administrators were reviewing the alternative plans from Collier and Cragin. Trujillo said they were. An audience member shouted "liar" and was warned that another outburst would lead to removal.
  • Written comments: Shaw asked to have written comments read aloud. Luna Rose said that would take about an hour and asked that they be sent to board members instead, so the board would have time for questions before its sign language interpreters' 10 p.m. stop. They weren't read aloud.

What's next

The board meets Dec. 1 to review ways to save money on transportation and to ask questions about the closures. The vote is Dec. 8 at Palo Verde High School.

This report was drafted by Claude Opus 5.5 from a live transcript produced by Deepgram Nova-2, then reviewed and edited by Nicholas De Leon with Claude Opus 5.5, and published at 10:18 PM MST on November 17, 2026. Read more about how this is made.